[Qsi_beneficiaries] Presentation for tomorrow (Feedback most welcome!)

[Andreas Hülsing]

Hi Marcos,


>
> Thanks! I have corrected all.
>
Thanks.
> Only in the case of "Information is encoded in millions of photons" I 
> added "(In case optical channels are used)". With this I just want to 
> make the point that QKD works in a quantum domain while PQC in a 
> classical one (and the number of photons is a way to illustrate it). 
> Hope this is fine! Otherwise, please let me know.
>
Well, luckily the information we are sending is not millions of bits. I 
do not know how many photons you need to actually encode a logical bit 
but I guess we are not in the millions. Also, are there actual 
implementations that implement QKD and use a single photon to encode a 
single state? Even then, you are comparing apples and oranges as you are 
talking about the full communication in the one case and a single state 
in the other (QKD also needs a classical channel, requires far more than 
one state, etc.pp.) [sorry for the nitpicking]

Cheers,

Andy

> Cheers,
> Marcos.
>
>
>
> 14 December 2023 at 17:41, "Andreas Hülsing" <andreas en huelsing.net 
> <mailto:andreas en huelsing.net?to=%22Andreas%20H%C3%BClsing%22%20%3Candreas%40huelsing.net%3E>> 
> wrote:
>
>     Hi Marcos,
>
>     looks good. Only comments:
>
>     - "Leading theorists group" I may use "theory" here but maybe one
>     of the native speakers should comment on this.
>
>     - "Information is encoded in millions of photons" for PQC... not
>     sure how this makes sense in this context... it may not be encoded
>     in any photons depending on the physical channel...
>
>     - "Security against quantum adversaries yet to be established" for
>     PQC... I am sorry but this is giving the wrong impression (and
>     using the QKD hyping language). " Established in terms of
>     cryptanalysis" would be more appropriate with the oral explanation
>     that this cannot give absolute certainty if you want to add that.
>
>     Thanks,
>
>     Andy
>
>     On 14-12-2023 15:02, mcurty en vqcc.uvigo.es wrote:
>
>         Hi Chris,
>         Thanks for pointing this out. Please find below a link to a
>         pdf version (though the upper and lower margins change):
>         https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/g5bbuxz9nnyhzu8e9awlt/Presentation-QSI.pdf?rlkey=31s9ahuv2abg5nu5yxcycpa7o&dl=0
>         <https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/g5bbuxz9nnyhzu8e9awlt/Presentation-QSI.pdf?rlkey=31s9ahuv2abg5nu5yxcycpa7o&dl=0>
>         Cheers,
>         Marcos.
>
>         14 December 2023 at 14:42, "Christian Majenz" <chmaj en dtu.dk
>         <mailto:chmaj en dtu.dk?to=%22Christian%20Majenz%22%20%3Cchmaj%40dtu.dk%3E>>
>         wrote:
>
>             The Dropbox preview of this presentation does not work for
>             me (I see only the title slide). I can download it and
>             view it with keynote (not sure whether people on Win/Linux
>             can see it).
>             ~~~~
>             Christian Majenz
>             Associate Professor
>             DTU Compute
>             chmaj en dtu.dk
>             Website: https://www.christianmajenz.info
>
>                 On 14 Dec 2023, at 14.39, mcurty en vqcc.uvigo.es wrote:
>                 Dear all,
>                 You can find here a first draft of the presentation I
>                 am preparing for tomorrow:
>                 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/s9k3yuwpnjr00kxy4kft9/Presentation-QSI.key?rlkey=kt8y93nfkmludrurlvu0vwdfx&dl=0
>                 <https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/s9k3yuwpnjr00kxy4kft9/Presentation-QSI.key?rlkey=kt8y93nfkmludrurlvu0vwdfx&dl=0>
>                 This afternoon/evening I will continue polishing it
>                 and I will include some missing information (like e.g.
>                 that related to recruitment). The first slides could
>                 be used to help in the Tour de Table. Please check
>                 that your information is correct! Any
>                 comments/suggestions are most welcome!
>                 Cheers,
>                 Marcos.
>                 -- 
>                 Qsi_beneficiaries mailing list
>                 Qsi_beneficiaries en qsiproject.eu
>                 https://listas.qsiproject.eu/listinfo/qsi_beneficiaries
>
>
------------ próxima parte ------------
Se ha borrado un adjunto en formato HTML...
URL: <http://listas.qsiproject.eu/pipermail/qsi_beneficiaries/attachments/20231214/bf2b4c5d/attachment-0001.htm>